Firmness: Just like a traditional mattress, mail order mattresses come in a range from very soft to very firm. Very soft, squishy mattresses can lack support and make for an uncomfortable sleeping experience, but very firm mattresses can cause pain and make it hard to sleep at all.
Everyone’s sleeping preferences are unique, but most will settle on something between the middle of the two extremes.
Composition (Foam vs. Springs): Most mail order mattresses will be made out of some type of foam. Not only is foam comfortable, but it is much easier to ship than a traditional mattress. However, some mail order mattresses will have some springs or other materials shoring up the foam. It’s up to you what materials you want your mattresses to be made of!
Temperature Features: Some people overheat when they sleep, while others can’t get warm enough. Since most people prefer a cooler sleeping experience and memory foam tends to trap in heat, many mail order mattresses will include features to keep their occupants from getting uncomfortably warm. Obviously, the temperature of your sleeping experience can vary greatly depending on the other materials and fabrics you use in your bed, but making sure a mattress leans toward your sleeping preferences is a good place to start.
Hypoallergenic Materials: Many mail order mattresses are made of hypoallergenic materials so that you don’t have to worry about their composition and how it will affect your good night’s sleep.
Water Resistance: A mail order mattress can come with water resistant features, meaning that liquids that end up in your bed won’t ruin the mattress. If you think this may be a concern for you, make sure to get a mattress that has this perk.
Reversibility: Unlike a traditional mattress, not every mail order mattress can be flipped. Some have layers that are meant to go on the top or on the bottom and they can’t be switched. If you think this would be an inconvenience, make sure to go for a reversible model.
Stain Resistance: Mistakes are inevitable, and the first time your kid spills grape juice on your bed, you’re going to wish you had a stain resistant mattress.
Ease of Set Up: A traditional mattress can just be plunked on your bed and covered in sheets, but a mail order mattress often has a set-up process. Luckily, this process is usually easy and just involves letting the mattress’ foam expand.
Trial Period: Some companies offer a trial period to let you use the mattress before you decide if it’s right for you. If making the perfect purchase is important to you, it may pay off to select a company that offers a trial period so that you can be sure that you’ve chosen the mattress that fits all of your needs.
Warranty: Most mail order mattresses come with a warranty, meaning that the manufacturer will repair or replace it, if necessary within a certain amount of time.
Budget: How much money you’re willing to spend on a mail order mattress is a key factor in your decision. While we all like to save our hard-earned money, sometimes you get what you pay for. It may not be best to buy the most expensive mattress you can find, but it probably won’t pay off to choose the least expensive, either. Take a look at the price range of mail order mattresses and decide on your budget before you buy.
Shipping: Since mattresses are big, they cost a lot of money to ship. Many companies, however, offer free shipping, saving you the cost of delivery.
What is the Best Mail Order Mattress for a Side Sleeper?
Depending on the position in which you sleep, you’re going to want a different firmness in your mattress. A side sleeper needs a softer mattress to avoid creating pressure in their hips and shoulders, while someone who sleeps on their back or stomach is going to want more firmness to support their spine.
If you love the feel of memory foam and you want medium-firm support, then you might want to put Nectar on your short list. Rapidly gaining a reputation as one of the best mail order mattresses in the business,
Nectar features high-density memory foam that’s guaranteed to stand the test of time – so much so, that the company offers a “Forever” warranty against defects for as long as the original purchaser owns the mattress.
Nectar mattresses feature five layers, each with a distinct purpose. The breathable base layer is designed to provide stability and prevent excessive sinking.
An adaptive hi core memory foam layer rests on top of the base. This recovery foam layer provides a combination of support, bounce, and pleasant rebound.
Next is a gel memory foam layer, which provides a combination of cooling, contouring, and reliable weight distribution.
A layer of quilted gel memory foam provides even more air circulation while imparting a pleasant, contouring feel. A Tencel cooling cover wicks away moisture and heat, helping you sleep comfortably.
It comes in all sizes, is suitable for all foundations and frames, and can be set up for a small fee. Like most other mail order mattress companies, Nectar offers financing if needed.
High-quality components for comfort and longevity
Best-in-class warranty and trial period
Life time warranty
Affordable price, with financing available
Some reports of negative interactions with customer service department
A little more “new product smell” than some competitors
Thinking about a hybrid mattress, but nervous about the cost? The DreamCloud Sleep mattress is definitely worth a look, particularly if you’re looking for a medium-firm feel. While this company is newer than some others, it has made its way onto our list of the best mail order mattresses for a few very good reasons.
DreamCloud’s engineering team did an excellent job with this design. It all begins with a tufted cashmere-blend Euro top, which provides exceptional breathability and plenty of softness while offering a feel that’s rated 3x cooler than most other materials, including cotton.
A layer of gel-infused memory foam offers cool, contouring support, and underneath that, a layer of quilted memory foam enhances air flow while providing a comfortable embrace.
The fourth layer is made up of natural latex, which provides a pleasant touch of bounce and prevents the sinking feeling that is so common in many memory foam mattresses.
The next two layers are made with high-density and super-dense memory foam, which enhance the supportive feel.
The seventh layer features DreamCloud’s patent-pending BestRest coils, which are divided into five zones for head-to-toe support.
The base layer is made with high-density super soft memory foam, which enhances the mattress’s luxurious feel while preventing motion transference.
A 365-night trial period provides ample time for testing in all kinds of temperatures. These mattresses come in all sizes, with free delivery and optional white-glove service for a small additional fee. Financing is available if needed.
Premium materials for durability and longevity
15 inches thick, with 8 layers for outstanding support and comfort
Good pressure relief
Suitable for all sleeping positions
Some people find it feels too firm
High height is a turnoff for some consumers
Modway Aveline 6” Gel Infused Memory Foam Twin Mattress
If you want a simple shopping experience, the Modway Aveline might be the choice for you. Instead of wading through oodles of options, you merely choose the size you want (twin, full, queen, or king) and the height you want (6, 8, or 10 inch) and click “Add to Cart!”
The memory foam top layer (open-cell, ventilated, and gel-infused) is designed to align your spine and reduce pressure on your hips, lower back, and shoulders.
It’s not too firm and not too soft, making it a great choice for those who like their mattresses “just right.” The memory foam also serves to reduce the disturbance and bouncing that you might feel when your sleeping partner moves.
While the memory foam keeps its firmness over time, some might prefer more layers between the soft upper half and the firmer bottom half.
The entire mattress is made without harmful materials, but the smell when you first open it might have you thinking otherwise. Luckily, that smell takes under a week to dissipate, and is usually gone after a single day.
The set-up process is super easy: it comes rolled up, and all you have to do is unroll it! It will be mostly-expanded after two to four hours, and completely expanded within a day.
The Aveline comes with a cover and a 10-year warranty. Use of a foundation or box spring is optional.
This mattress might be a little on the pricey side compared to competitors of similar quality, but most customers agree that it’s totally worth it.
Lots of options
Easy to set up
Only two layers
Noticeable smell when first opened
Signature Sleep 12-Inch Premium Cool Gel Memory Foam Mattress
This hybrid queen-size mattress from Signature Sleep has three layers: on top, a 2-inch layer of gel-infused memory foam; in the middle, a 1.5-inch layer of responsive memory foam that prevents disturbances resulting from the motion of someone else in the bed; and an 8.5-inch layer of high density support foam.
These three layers provide balanced support for your head, neck, shoulders, hips, and spine while also increasing air circulation and cooling you down.
The issue with this mattress seems to be its firmness. While some reviewers say that it is much too firm, most reviewers say it’s on the soft side and doesn’t provide as much support as it should. It’s rated at medium-soft, meaning that those who need a firmer sleeping experience should look elsewhere.
It is advertised as expanding to its full size within 48 hours of opening it, but some customers report that their mattress never inflated completely, even after weeks.
Different layers of material prevent sleepers from sinking too far into the mattress
Includes cooling system
Too soft for many customers
Snuggle-Pedic Mattress That Breathes – Patented Airflow System
While the Snuggle-Pedic mattress is more expensive than the other options above, that’s because of its great features and superior customer service.
120-night refund guarantee
free firmness adjustment layer exchanges
This mattress (which comes in any size, including twin, twin XL, full, queen, and king) has a pressure relief surface and a firmer lower layer.
The upper layer combines both ventilation holes and channels, while other brands use just one or the other, so this mattress has the best chance of keeping you cool.
The materials, which are free of that chemical smell, are hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant. However, some folks say this mattress is much too soft.
Now we’ve come to the real reason to buy this mattress: the customer service.
In addition to a 20-year warranty, this mattress comes with a 120-night trial period with a refund guarantee.
If you aren’t completely satisfied, the company will send you more layers to adjust the firmness! This may be one of the best mattresses to buy online, since you aren’t flying blind like you might be with other purchases.
Great trial period and exchange policy
Advanced cooling systems
Free of chemical smell
Too soft for some people
Best Mail Order Mattress – Final Thoughts
Obviously, budget makes a huge difference when it comes to mail order mattresses, since they come in such a wide range of prices.
Once you’ve decided on a budget, the next step is deciding the firmness of your ideal mattress. (If you aren’t sure, you can take a field trip down to your local mattress store and test some out. I know you wanted to shop from home, but it’s better than buying a mattress you don’t want!)
Thirdly, you need to decide if you end up too cold or too hot in bed, and therefore what kind of cooling system you want. Mail order mattresses tend to run hot, so don’t underestimate your temperature needs!
What is the best mail order mattress for you? Let us know in the comments below!