If you’re the parent of a little one, you know that you might have to replace some of your baby’s items. This is especially true if you have multiple kids. Perhaps you have been using the same Pack n Play for several years and want a new one. Maybe you just bought a Pack n Play and would like a newer, nicer mattress.

Quick Look at Our Top 5 Picks

No matter why you want to replace it, you will have plenty of options. Pack n Play mattresses are easy to find, which means you’re left with some tough decisions. Most parents use their Pack n Plays for travel or as play pens at home. This means that it’s not as important as a regular crib, but you should still try to get a decent mattress.

When you begin searching for a new Pack n Play mattress, you will want to be sure that the mattress you choose is compatible with the Graco Pack n Play. There are many other things to keep in mind, so this could get complicated.

To make this search easier, we’ve simplified things. First, let’s take a look at some of the most essential factors when it comes to buying a new Pack n Play mattress. Then, you will see our list of top picks.

What Should I Consider When Shopping for a Mattress for Graco Pack n Play?

When it’s time to replace your Graco Pack n Play mattress, there are a few things to keep in mind. You want to make sure that you look into each of these considerations so that you can buy the best mattress for your little one!

  • Price:You shouldn’t spend too much on a Graco Pack n Play mattress because your child will only need to use it for a couple of years. If you have more than one child who will use the Pack n Play, it can be worth it to spend a little bit more. In order to get the best deal on a new mattress, you should look online for price comparisons and sales. This can save you a lot of money if you do it right.If you are wanting to come up with a budget for a Graco Pack n Play mattress, it can be beneficial to look at a few of your options. This should give you a reasonable price range to plan for.
  • Durability: Durability can be an important part of any mattress decision, but it’s especially important for Pack n Play mattresses. Most people use Pack n Plays for travel. If you fly, your Pack n Play and the mattress might get tossed around. Additionally, you don’t want to feel like you have to be careful when you are transporting the travel crib.Another consideration to make is how many children will be using the Pack n Play. If several of your kids will use it over the years, you should look for a more durable option that can stand up to plenty of use.To check if a mattress is going to be durable enough, you can look at product reviews from people who have used the mattress for a couple of years. If you see complaints about the mattress showing wear immediately, that’s usually a bad sign.
  • Warranty: Warranties are more common on other types of mattresses. Still, some Pack n Play mattresses do come with warranties. If this extra protection is important to you, then you should look for a Pack n Play mattress that offers a warranty. This isn’t always necessary, but it’s nice to know that you can have the mattress fixed or replaced if a problem arises.Before purchasing a Pack n Play mattress with a warranty, make sure you know what the warranty covers. Some are very limited and others are more generous. This is sometimes reflected in the price of the product too.
  • Ease of Cleaning: As with anything that you buy for your little ones to use, you want to make sure that mattresses can be cleaned easily. You don’t want to have to go through a ton of work when you realize that your baby spit up during the night or their diaper leaked all over the mattress.Luckily, many Pack n Play mattresses are easy to clean. Some are even waterproof! If you like a Pack n Play mattress that isn’t waterproof, you can buy a waterproof mattress cover to put between the mattress and the sheets.
  • Portability: Since you will be traveling with a Pack n Play mattress, you want to make sure that it’s easy to take on the go. Many of them do fold up pretty small and can even fit in the same case as the Pack n Play itself.This is definitely something to look for because you don’t want to have to carry yet another thing into the hotel or a grandparent’s home!
  • Brand: When it comes to finding a Graco Pack n Play mattress, you might be tempted to buy the Graco brand. While this does make sense, it’s not the most cost-effective option. Additionally, you could be missing out on some other mattresses that fit perfectly in your Graco Pack n Play.If the brand is important to you, you can go for the Graco mattress. Otherwise most other brands should work well.
  • Compatibility:If you do decide to purchase a Pack n Play mattress from a brand other than Graco, you should make sure that it will work with the Pack n Play you have. Additionally, you will want to make sure that it fits with any other accessories that you have, such as sheets or waterproof covers.

Best Mattress for Graco Pack n Play Reviews

We’ve rounded up some of the very best mattresses that you can buy to replace your Graco Pack n Play mattress. There are some great options out there, so you can’t go wrong with any of these.

Make sure you keep your preferences in mind—along with your baby’s—to ensure that you all get a good night’s sleep! We did rank these mattresses from best to worst, but they are all very reasonable choices. Your own personal needs do need to come into play when making such significant purchases. Take a look at our favorites and select the one that you like the most!

Dream On Me Foam Pack And Play Mattress

Our top pick for Pack n Play mattresses is the Dream On Me Foam Mattress. It’s comfortable and supportive for your little one. The cover prevents mold and odors, which is nice. It’s waterproof as well. To clean it, you can simply wipe it down! The cover can be a little bit too noisy for some users, but most sheets seem to resolve that problem.

The price is very affordable. Of all of the best Pack n Play mattresses, this one is priced in the middle. It comes with a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty. It fits perfectly in the Graco Pack n Play! One problem is that it can’t fold up for travel. It works great for anyone who doesn’t take their Pack n Play with them on the go.

Pros:

  • 10-year warranty
  • Fits in Graco Pack n Play
  • Waterproof
  • Prevents odors
  • Affordable
  • Softer than alternatives
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Too noisy for some users
  • Cannot fold for travel

Dream On Me Playard Mattress

As you probably noticed, our top two Pack n Play mattress options are from the same company. If you have the choice, you should go with a Dream On Me Pack n Play Mattress! This one is made of foam and vinyl. It’s got a waterproof cover, which is ready to prevent mold and odors.

It wipes down very easily as needed! It’s 3 inches thick, which is just about perfect for your little one. It’s comfortable but provides the necessary support. It might be too firm for some users. It’s lightweight and easy to travel with. Unfortunately, it cannot be folded down.

The price is pretty low and very affordable. A 10-year warranty is included too. Some users have noticed that there are gaps between the mattress and the Pack n Play, which can be unsafe to small children.

Pros:

  • 10-year warranty
  • Affordable
  • Waterproof
  • Easy to clean
  • Comfortable and supportive

Cons:

  • Can’t be folded down for travel
  • Might be too firm for some users.

LA Baby Waterproof Portable/Mini Crib Mattress

This mattress is another pretty good choice. It is made with high-density poly fiber. Its cover is hypoallergenic and antimicrobial. Plus, it’s waterproof and easy to clean! Some users have found that this is a bit too thin. Additionally, it can be loud when your child moves around.

The price is on the lower end, but the mattress is still very durable and good quality. If you’re looking for something for multiple children, it may be a smart idea to invest in a better mattress. The warranty only lasts for one year, but it’s better than not having a warranty at all. It’s a great fit for a Graco Pack n Play or a Port-a-Crib.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Fits in Graco Pack n Play
  • Waterproof
  • 1-year warranty
  • Easy to clean
  • Prevents odors

Cons:

  • Too thin for some users
  • Shorter warranty than other options
  • Can’t be folded down for travel
  • Makes noise when babies move

Folding Pack N Play Mattress by Sproutwise Kids

If you’re on the hunt for an organic, healthy alternative to a Pack n Play mattress, this one is for you! It’s got a soft cotton cover made from organic materials. The inside is made of natural latex foam to give baby optimal comfort! You can buy this mattress in two different size options, so make sure that you get the right one for your Pack n Play.

This mattress is on the higher end as far as pricing goes. It’s definitely worth the extra money to get such a great product. The warranty information is not available. It’s easy to travel with. It has a tri-fold style, which is simple to fold up and take on the go. It’s also easy to wash as needed.

Note that it might not fit in all Pack n Plays, so be sure to measure.

Pros:

  • Easy to travel with
  • Organic materials
  • 2 size options
  • Easy to wash
  • Comfortable

Cons:

  • No warranty information
  • More expensive than alternatives
  • May not fit all Pack n Plays

NapYou Amazon Exclusive Pack N Play Mattress

This is a foam mattress with a comfortable organic cotton cover. The mattress includes a carrying bag so that you can fold it up and take it on the go. The mattress is divided into sections so it can be folded into three parts. Some users have noted that the strap on the traveling bag breaks easily. The mattress is comfortable, but it provides the right firmness for your little one’ safety!

One downside is that it has a strong smell when you first open it and set it up. This will fade away after a couple of days, but it can really bother some users. The price is higher than the other options due to the organic cotton and the overall design. It’s worth the extra money if you can afford it!

The warranty information about this product isn’t available.

Pros:

  • Organic cotton
  • Comfortable
  • Easy to take on the go
  • Durable
  • Fits in Graco Pack n Play
  • Lightweight

Cons:

  • Strong smell
  • Extra bag to carry
  • Less affordable than alternatives
  • Strap on bag breaks easily
  • No warranty information

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for the perfect replacement mattress for a Graco Pack n Play, we’ve got the options you need. It’s important to do your research so that you know exactly what you want and what you’re getting. Plus, your baby’s sleeping situation can determine yours as well. If they’re uncomfortable, you might be up all night.

There are countless Graco Pack n Play mattresses available, which means you have a lot to choose from. This choice doesn’t have to be impossible though. It’s worth the extra considerations and research in the end. Before you begin shopping, make sure you know what you’re looking for. It’s best to have some background information before going in blindly and making a fast decision.

Think about what’s most essential to you in a Graco Pack n Play mattress. Not every parent is looking for the same things, so you need to consider what you or your baby needs. Luckily, all of the mattresses that we selected are some of the best. You won’t be missing out on any fancy features and you won’t be getting a low-quality mattress.

About Dabora Dabora is Chief editor at Sleeping Culture. She is a proud mother of two, passionate about sleep and finding ways to live a healthier and stress-free lifestyle.


If you’ve got a little one on the way, you’re probably looking for the safest and healthiest baby items for them. If you haven’t thought about it, an organic crib mattress is a great way to protect your baby from chemicals. Some people don’t know that standard mattresses are made with toxic materials, which can be unsafe for humans overtime. By using an organic mattress, you will be reducing the amount of chemicals that you or your baby come into contact with.

Quick Look At Our Top 5 Picks

Organic mattresses are made up of safer materials and are treated with alternatives to flame retardants. What’s great is that there are plenty of organic mattresses available. Likewise, you can find an organic crib mattress for your baby!

Babies spend much of their day sleeping, especially when they are newborns. Having an organic crib mattress is an extra way to protect them from dangerous chemicals. It’s definitely worth the extra work and research to find an organic crib mattress.

We’ve explained some of the most important considerations to make when it comes to shopping for an organic crib mattress. Then, we have highlighted some of the best organic crib mattresses for your baby so that you don’t have to do the hard work!

What Should I Consider When Shopping for an Organic Crib Mattress?

If you’re wanting to purchase an organic crib mattress for your baby, there are few things that you should keep in mind when you begin shopping. It’s important to find a mattress that meets your personal preferences. Since your little one will be sleeping on it, you will want to make sure that it’s comfortable for them as well.

  1. Price: Crib mattresses are pretty affordable in general. Organic options are going to be somewhat more expensive, but the price difference is totally worth it. Take a look at several different organic crib mattresses to get an idea of how much they cost. Then you can make a reasonable decision as far as your budget goes. If you are trying to save money, you should look online for crib mattresses. You will be able to see price comparisons and look for sales more easily this way. Be on the lookout for coupon codes and free shipping as well!
  2. Warranty: Some mattresses, of any type, come complete with a warranty. This will protect you in case of any issues with the mattress. These sometimes exist with crib mattresses, but they might not be very useful. This is because most people only use crib mattresses for a couple of years. Mattresses can usually hold up for that long without a need for a warranty to be used. Still, it’s a nice option to have. It can definitely come in handy if you have multiple children using the same crib mattress over several years.
  3. Materials: When you’re looking at organic crib mattresses, you’ll see that they are made up of organic or chemical-free materials. If you know you want an organic mattress, you probably already know the dangers of some of the chemicals used on standard crib mattresses.
  4. Size: If you are shopping for a crib mattress after you have already purchased a crib, you should take measurements of the crib. Most crib mattresses fit a standard sized crib, but this isn’t true in all cases. To be on the safe side, look for a crib mattress that is the same size as the crib. Sometimes, even if a crib is supposed to be the standard size, a standard sized mattress won’t fit. It’s important to use exact measurements to be exactly sure.
  5. Durability: Durability is more important in adult mattresses because they are used long-term. Still, it’s nice to know that your baby’s mattress is going to hold up over time. Durability can be tricky to measure until you start using the mattress. Luckily, you can use reviews to hear from people who have been using the mattress for several months or a year. If it shows major signs of wear right away, it may not be a good choice. You should look for a more durable option if you will be using the same crib mattress for multiple babies. This will also be a better investment than buying a new crib mattress each time you have another child.
  6. Fireproof: One reason that standard crib mattresses contain so many chemicals is because they are treated with flame retardants. The purpose of these chemicals is to prevent your baby’s mattress from catching on fire in case a fire happens. Unfortunately, the chemicals used are very dangerous for little ones. Organic crib mattresses are often still fireproof, so be sure to double check on that. You might have thought you can’t get an organic mattress that is fireproof, but most still meet the flammability requirements!
  7. Firmness: If you feel a crib mattress, you will quickly notice that they aren’t nearly as comfortable or plush as regular mattresses are. This is a good thing though! It keeps babies safe. Infants should sleep on a firmer surface in order to make sure they can breathe at all times. Some crib mattresses can be too plush or cause danger to little ones. If a crib mattress is listed as being plush, you should probably choose a different one in order to keep your baby safe.
  8. WaterproofnessLittle ones often have diaper leaks and other spills in their beds. Because of this, you should look for a crib mattress that has a waterproof cover. If you can’t find one that you like, you can buy a waterproof cover to slide over any crib mattress. No parent wants to deal with cleaning a complicated crib mattress in the middle of the night. Having a waterproof mattress or cover simplifies the process and lets parents get back to bed sooner.

5 Best Organic Crib Mattress Reviews

All of the mattresses that have made this list are organic. They haven’t been treated with toxic fireproof chemicals, but they meet the requirements for flammability. This means that you can worry less about fire hazards and chemicals at the same time.

Any of the mattresses we’ve selected would be an excellent resting spot for your little one!  You will want to think about your own personal preferences as you shop for a crib mattress. We’ll outline a few of those major considerations and preferences later.

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Crib Mattress

View On Amazon

The Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress is our favorite organic crib mattress. In addition to being organic and chemical free, it’s also allergy-friendly.

This mattress is easy to clean, as it’s waterproof. It has seamless edges, adding to the ease of cleaning. It’s a spring mattress with 150 coils. It’s about six inches thick, which is just right. It’s firm, which is recommended for babies. You can flip this mattress to the softer side and use it in a toddler bed.

It comes complete with a lifetime warranty, which is one reason that this mattress shines brighter than the rest on this list. The price is a little bit higher than the other mattresses we’ve selected. It’s definitely worth it!

Pros:

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Allergy-friendly
  • Easy to clean
  • Firm
  • Dual sided

Cons:

  • Might be too expensive for some users
  • Might be too firm for some users

Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress

View On Amazon

The Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress is another organic option for anyone who wants to keep their baby free from the effects of chemicals. It’s covered in a breathable material, which works to lower the risks of suffocation. It’s made out of a unique Wovenaire Core. This contains 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer.

The comfort level of this organic crib mattress is similar to that of foam or latex. It’s much safer than those options though! It’s the perfect blend of firm and soft, so it can be used for both infants and toddlers.

This mattress is fully washable, making it easy to clean at any time of day or night. It works well at keeping your baby cool as well so that they don’t get too hot. It might be a little bit on the more expensive side like the previous option. It’s worth the extra money to keep your baby safe and comfortable.

Pros:

  • Can be used for both infants and toddlers
  • Fully washable
  • Breathable to keep baby cool

Cons:

  • No warranty information available
  • Might be too expensive for some users

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

View On Amazon

The Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress is an orthopedic style mattress made of foam and cotton. The mattress itself is made from plant oils and is eco-friendlier than many other options. In addition to the cover being organic, it’s hypoallergenic and free of phthalates. The cotton cover is waterproof to help with cleaning up leaks and spills during the night.

It has two different sides with unique levels of firmness. It can be used on the firm side for infants or the plusher side for toddlers! This makes it great option for parents who want to use the mattress long-term.

This option is quite a bit cheaper than the previous two options. This doesn’t mean that it’s a compromise on quality at all though. It’s still very durable and a reasonable organic crib mattress choice.

The company offers a warranty for as long as you own the mattress.

Pros:

  • More affordable than other options
  • Dual-sided
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Lightweight
  • Waterproof

Cons:

  • May not be 100% organic
  • Still might be too expensive for some users

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

View On Amazon

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress is made out of a hypoallergenic soy foam. This makes for a firm mattress that is perfect for both infants and toddlers.

This crib mattress’s cover is waterproof, so it can be wiped clean or washed easily. It’s also breathable to keep your little one safe. It’s more affordable than the previous options listed.

One downside is that it may not be as durable as some of the other options. Since this mattress will only be used for a couple of years, this shouldn’t be too big of an issue. Still, it’s something to keep in mind if you wanted to use it for multiple kids.

Pros:

  • Warranty
  • Can be used for toddlers and infants
  • Waterproof cover
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Not as durable as other options

BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Crib and Toddler Mattress


View On Amazon

The BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Crib and Toddler Mattress is the last on our list, but it’s still a great choice! Like the previous option, it is made of a soybean core, which is pretty firm. This is safe for little ones, because mattresses that are too plush can mean decreased breathability.

It fits in most cribs and toddler beds, so it’s a nice option for transitioning little ones. This is the least expensive organic crib mattress that ended up on our list. It’s great for anyone on a budget or anyone who doesn’t want to spend a lot of money on a crib mattress.

BeautySleep doesn’t have warranty information available, so there might not be a warranty.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Firm
  • Square corners to fit cribs better

Cons:

  • Too firm for some users
  • No warranty information

Best Organic Crib Mattress – Final Thoughts

Overall, we like the Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress the most. It’s got the most impressive features and has just about everything your little one needs. It should work for most babies and their parents.

Of course, as mentioned before, any of the mattresses on this list are excellent choices. They are all safer for your baby than some alternatives. They are also all relatively affordable. One bonus that most of these mattresses offer is that they can be used for both infants and toddlers. Some are even double sided to give your infant a firm surface and your toddler a plusher side.

It’s important for your baby to have a cozy place to sleep. You also want to make sure that the organic crib mattress you choose is easy to wash and fits in the crib well. It might seem tricky to find the perfect crib mattress, but it will be well worth it!

When you are making your final decision, you should keep our list of considerations in mind so that you make the best choice for your little one. The factors that come into play should be the ones that matter the most to you. This should help you to narrow your search!

About Aubrey Meister Audrey is an English teacher and writer. She enjoys the Florida beach life with her husband and puppy.