Best Toddler Mattress

toddler sitting on a comfortable bed

Maybe your child is ready to upgrade from a crib to a toddler bed or a regular bed. You might be wondering what type of mattress to get for your child and what to consider when shopping for one. This can be a confusing time. Since your little one will only use a toddler mattress for a couple of years, you might be tempted to look for the cheapest option available, but you still want to make sure you get a quality mattress that provides the support that a child needs. Thankfully, there are more than enough toddler bed mattresses that you can buy online that are both high quality and affordable.

You might be wondering if all toddler beds are the same size or if you will have to take some measurements. You might also be trying to decide what type of mattress to buy. There’s a lot to consider when it comes to choosing a toddler mattress, so we will break things down and make the process a little bit easier.

Quick Look at Our Top 5 Picks

  • Perfect mix of comfort and support
  • CertiPUR-US Certified memory foams
  • Comes with a 101-night trial
  • Comfortable foam
  • Water-resistant, washable cover
  • Good for crib and bed
  • Comes with waterproof liner
  • Firm and comfortable
  • Good value for money
  • Dual sided – one for infants, one for toddlers
  • Very durable
  • Made with medical grade fabric
  • Firm but comfortable
  • GreenGuard Gold certified
  • Waterproof cover

5 Best Rated Toddler Mattresses Reviewed

We’ve found some of the best toddler mattresses available and created a list of our top five favorite options. These are all great choices, but as with all things, some will be more suitable for some users than others. Keep your own personal preferences in mind as you’re shopping to make sure you’re getting what you and your child need.

Puffy Mattress


View On Puffy

Both comfort and support are essential for growing children and the Puffy Mattress delivers the ideal combination of both. Made from climate-adaptive materials like gel-infused Cooling Cloud foam and ClimateComfort foam, this mattress will keep your child cool on even the hottest nights. Add the ultra-adaptive contouring of the Puffy Lux’s layer of Dual Cloud foam and your child will feel like he is sleeping on a cloud each time he goes to bed.

The Puffy Mattress comes in two levels of firmness and a 101-night trial so your child can decide if it’s the right fit. Both models offer reduced motion transfer, contouring support for proper spinal alignment, and a consistent level of comfort no matter the climate. Simply put, it is designed to deliver a comfortable night’s sleep each and every night.

Though not specifically designed for use in cribs or as toddler bed mattresses, the Puffy Mattress is made from premium-quality materials and hand-crafted in the USA. When your child is ready to move to a full-size bed, the Puffy Mattress offers two levels of firmness and a wide variety of sizes to choose from.


  • Offers the ideal combination of comfort and support
  • Made from CertiPUR-US Certified memory foams
  • Comes with a 101-night trial and lifetime warranty


  • Not specifically designed for use in cribs or toddler beds
  • May be more expensive than other models

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

View On Amazon

The Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress is what we consider to be the best toddler bed mattress.

This is a crib and toddler mattress, which means you can use it for both babies and toddlers. This makes the transition easier on the little one if they’re already used to the feeling of their crib mattress.

It’s made out of comfortable foam, which allows for plenty of air flow. This can lead to deeper and better quality sleep. It’s five inches thick, which is pretty standard for crib and toddler bed mattresses. The mattress is also GreenGuard Gold certified, meaning that the mattress has no toxic materials.

It’s also one of the most affordable options on the list, and you won’t have  to compromise on quality!

It also comes with a 6-year warranty, which can give you a peace of mind about your purchase. Although most people won’t need to use a crib mattress and a toddler mattress for this long, if you have multiple children who will be using the mattress, this can certainly be helpful and save a bit of money!


  • Can be used for cribs and beds
  • Waterproof liner
  • Comfortable foam
  • Heat and air ventilation
  • Anti-flame materials
  • 6-year warranty


  • Can take 24 hours or more to fully expand

Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress

View On Amazon

The Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress is a close second to the previous option. It’s very affordable and has a handful of impressive features.

It’s made of foam, which is comfortable and a safe material for little ones to sleep on as it foam allows for heat and air ventilation.

This mattress is also waterproof, which is important for toddler beds. The waterproof cover goes around the mattress as a liner. Small children who are potty training might wet the bed. Over time, this can result in damage to the mattress. Having a liner or a cover makes it easier to clean a mattress as well.

In addition to being waterproof, it’s made of anti-flame materials to keep your child safe.


  • Waterproof liner
  • Firm, comfortable foam
  • Heat and air ventilation
  • Anti-flame materials


  • The liner might not be durable enough for some users

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

View On Amazon

The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress is the most expensive option to make this list and it’s definitely worth the extra money if you can afford it!

The mattress has two sides. One side is firm, which is ideal for newborns and infants. The other side is plush, which is softer and perfect for a toddler. It’s truly designed to be both a crib mattress and a toddler bed mattress! Some parents have switched between the two sides depending on how their child is sleeping, which can be a nice option.

It’s 5 inches thick, which is the standard thickness. The mattress is also made out of medical grade fabric, which makes it particularly suitable for children with allergies or have sensitive skin.

The cover is waterproof, but it’s not removable. This can prevent staining, but you may want to add a removable cover so that you can wash it easily.


  • Dual sided
  • Medical grade fabric
  • Very durable


  • Waterproof cover isn’t removable

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

View On Amazon

The Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress is made of interwoven coils, which make for a firm mattress. This provides the support that a growing child needs.

The mattress is antibacterial and waterproof, so it’s great for toddlers who are potty training. It’s also made of hypoallergenic material so it’s also suitable for children who have sensitive skin. If you’re concerned about chemicals, then you’ll be happy to know that this mattress is GreenGuard Gold certified to meet American standards for a healthy indoor environment for your baby.

One downside is that the plastic waterproof cover can be a bit noisy.


  • Waterproof
  • Affordable
  • Can be used for cribs and infant beds
  • Firm support


  • Some users found the mattress cover too noisy

Additional Toddler Mattresses We Reviewed

1. Big Oshi Foam Crib Mattress

This 5” foam mattress fits both cribs and toddler beds. It has a waterproof and hypoallergenic vinyl cover that makes clean ups easy. Excellent quality and proudly manufactured in the USA.

Key features:

  • Made in the USA
  • Waterproof and hypoallergenic
  • Fits both cribs and toddler beds

2. Dourxi Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Somewhat pricier, but this dual sided toddler mattress is made of CertiPUR-US certified memory foam. One side is firmer for babies and the other side is for toddlers with more cushioning. Comes with a washable cover.

Key features:

  • Dual sided
  • CertiPUR-US foam
  • Washable cover

3. Imagio Baby Premium Mattress

This is a dual sided mattress with one firmer side for infants, and a more cushioned side for toddlers. It’s made out of CertiPUR-US foam and is OEKO Tex 100 certified so you can be sure this meets the highest health and safety standards.

Key features:

  • Dual sided
  • CertiPUR-US foam
  • OEKO Tex 100 certified

4. Sealy Butterfly Waterproof Crib & Toddler Mattress

One of the most popular American mattress brands, Sealy also makes a great foam mattress for toddlers. It provides firm but comfortable support. Waterproof with removable cover.

Key Features:

  • Firm and comfortable
  • CertiPUR-US foam
  • Removable waterproof cover

5. Lullaby Earth Breathable Crib Mattress

Just like the name implies, this crib mattress is designed to allow air to flow directly under your baby with ease. It means that your baby can breathe right through the sleep surface. Aside from that, the breathable surface can be removed and washed. You do not have to worry about your baby falling off while sleeping as the mattress cover comes with a built-in protector pad to prevent this from happening.

The mattress cover also has a waterproof backing that will protect the mattress from liquids like urine and other messes. So, you can easily replace it with a spare pad while you wash the other one when necessary.

The Lullaby Earth crib mattress does not contain any chemicals. It meets the flammability requirements.

Key Features

  • Breathable surface
  • Built-in protector pad
  • Waterproof mattress core
  • No flame retardants. 

6. Clevr Premium Gel Memory Foam Mattress

This foam mattress is an excellent choice for toddlers. It has an extra layer of memory foam for additional cushioning and anti-slip dots on the bottom so the mattress always stays in place.

Key Features

  • Anti-slip
  • Layer of memory foam for comfort
  • Comes with washable bamboo cover

7. Dream on Me 2 in 1 Foam Core Crib and Toddler Mattress

This is an extra firm foam mattress that’s completely wet resistant. It’s GreenGuard Gold certified to ensure a safe and non-toxic environment. Made in the USA with soybean oils from American farmers.

Key Features:

  • Made in the USA with American materials
  • Extra firm
  • Waterproof

8. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

The Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Crib Mattress is designed to provide the firmness your baby needs when sleeping. It would help increase their development, strengthen their muscles, and ensure breathability in their crib.

Your baby gets to sleep comfortably as the mattress cover comes with an ultra-soft certified organic cotton cover, which is waterproof to ensure that the mattress stays dry. Even if your infant wets the bed while sleeping, they will not feel any inconvenience; hence their sleep will not be disrupted.

The best part is that this mattress is designed to last through the infant and toddler years, with upturned layers for extra durability. It means you can quickly flip the bed to the softer side as your child transitions to the toddler stage.

Key Features

  • Durable
  • 2-stage dual firmness
  • Waterproof backing
  • Breathable
  • Designed for both infants and toddlers

9. Sealy Prestige Posture Mattress

This Sealy toddler mattress uses inner coils for firmness and has 2 layers of hypoallergenic foam for cushioning and comfort.  The mattress is waterproof, down to the seams, so clean up is always easy.

Key Features

  • Coil mattress
  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic

10. Dourxi 3 Layer 6 Inch Crib & Toddler Mattress

This mattress uses 3 layers of foam with an open cell design to promote air flow so that your baby can sleep coolly. It’s firm enough for a baby and the side with memory foam will be perfect for toddlers.

Key Features

  • Very breathable
  • Good for babies and toddlers
  • Washable cover

11. Simmons Kids SlumberTime Naturally Foam Mattress

This is a crib and toddler mattress with an inner spring design for exceptional support, and an extra layer of foam for toddlers. It’s made in the USA and is also GreenGuard certified.

Key Features:

  • Made in the USA
  • Inner coil with layer of foam
  • Waterproof

12. Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

This is a crib and toddler mattress with an inner spring design for exceptional support, and an extra layer of foam for toddlers. It’s made in the USA and is also GreenGuard certified.

Key Features:

  • Made in the USA
  • Inner coil with layer of foam
  • Waterproof

13. Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress – Dual Sided Sleep System

This is a CertiPUR US certified foam mattress that’s a great choice for toddler beds. It has an anti-slip layer on the bottom to keep the mattress in place. It’s also an affordable choice.

Key features:

  • CertiPUR US foam mattress
  • Non-slip bottom
  • Budget friendly

14. NapYou Dual Side Comfort Crib Mattress

A firm foam mattress that has a more cushioned side for toddler, which is perfect for transitioning from crib to bed. The washable waterproof cover is made from organic cotton.

Key features:

  • CertiPUR US foam mattress
  • Waterproof cover from organic cotton
  • Comfortable and supportive

15. Comfort Crib Baby & Toddler Bed Mattress

This is a high density foam mattress that is firm and supportive. It’s lightweight so it’s quick and easy when you want to change the bedsheets. Comes with a removable fabric cover.

Key Features:

  • Firm, high density foam
  • Lightweight
  • Removable fabric cover

What Should I Consider When Shopping for a Toddler Mattress?

These are some of the factors that are important to keep in mind when you’re looking for a toddler It’s a good idea to create a list of your own personal preferences before you begin shopping. Then you will be able to narrow your search to what you are looking for in a toddler mattress.

Price: Price is an important consideration to make when you’re shopping for a toddler mattress. You want to make sure that the mattress is affordable, but you don’t want to compromise on quality.

Most crib and toddler mattresses are very low-cost because they will only be used for the first few years of your child’s life. If this is your first child and you are planning to have more children, then you might consider investing in a more expensive but also more durable mattress.

To get the best deal on a crib or toddler bed mattress, you should look online for sales. You can also view a wider range of products by shopping online instead of in a store.

Warranty and Trials: Not all toddler bed mattresses come equipped with a warranty. This isn’t a necessary factor, but it can be helpful when it comes to making a final decision.

Having the extra protection that a warranty brings can be very reassuring in case anything happens. Because you will likely only be using a toddler mattress for a couple of years, a lengthy warranty is not a necessity. If a warranty is important to you, be sure to look specifically for toddler mattresses and mattress companies that offer warranties.

Some mattress companies are also offering trial periods so you can see if your child sleeps well on it before committing to the purchase.

Versatility: As you probably noticed, several of the mattresses that made it on our list can be used for cribs and beds for toddlers. Look for what’s called a dual side mattress. These have a firmer side for infants and a more cushioned side for extra comfort when your child doesn’t need as much support. This kind of mattress can be a great investment and save you from making two separate purchases.

With a crib and toddler mattress, you will be set for longer and then can shop for another a nicer option when you are more relaxed as your family moves out of the newborn infant stage. The familiarity of the same mattress will also help your baby transition from the crib to a toddler bed.

Durability: Durability isn’t a huge concern when it comes to toddler mattresses. The main goal is to have a toddler mattress hold up to the couple years of use you’ll need it for. Some mattresses are better equipped to be used for multiple children.

Look for user reviews from people who have been using the mattress for a year or two to get a good idea of how well it holds up.

Waterproofness: Some mattresses come with a waterproof cover. These can be great in case of diaper leaks and for little ones who are still potty training and might still occasionally wet the bed.

Additionally, babies might spit up or young children might spill their drinks in their beds. With a waterproof mattress, cleanup is easy and you don’t have to worry about germs and bacteria. Many toddler mattresses come with waterproof removable covers that can be washed as needed. Not all waterproof covers are removable, so be sure to do your research. You can also buy a waterproof cover or a waterproof mattress pad to go over the mattress. There are usually very cheap and will save you a bunch of hassle.

Size: Most crib and toddler bed mattresses are designed to fit standard sized cribs and beds. Nonetheless, it’s still a good idea to take measurements of the crib or the toddler bed to avoid any unpleasant surprises when the mattress finally arrives.

If you want to buy a mattress for your child to use later on when they upgrade to a twin- or full-sized bed, you should look specifically for options that work well for toddlers. For example, you might look for the best twin mattress for toddlers or the best full mattress for toddlers.

Thickness: Most toddler mattresses are five inches thick. This can vary by company and by mattress type. If you’re looking for a particularly thick mattress for a toddler, these can be hard to find. Your options will be limited if you want a mattress thicker than five inches.

In most cases, five inches is the perfect thickness for a young child. This usually provides a firm but comfortable sleep for your little one!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a dual side mattress?

A dual side mattress is when one side is firmer for babies who need extra support, while the other side is more cushioned for more comfort for toddlers.

Will a crib mattress also fit a toddler bed?

Generally speaking yes, the sizes are the same. However, some cribs and beds come in non-standard sizes so it’ best to measure the bed before making a purchase.

How much should I spend on a toddler mattress?

We’ve listed a few budget toddler mattresses that cost around $50 and are decent quality. Depending on what features you’re looking for, the price can go up to a bit over $100. In any case, there are lots of affordable choices online!

Are toddler mattresses waterproof?

Many toddler mattresses are waterproof and can be easily wiped down for cleaning. Some of the more expensive ones will even make sure the seams are also waterproof to make sure there really is no room for bacteria and mold to grow.

Should I get a mattress cover for a toddler’s mattress?

As most toddler mattresses are waterproof, you can be fine without in most cases. However, in case yours isn’t, or if the waterproof cover isn’t removable, then it’s worth buying a cheap, washable mattress cover for easy cleaning.

My child has allergies. Are there hypoallergenic mattresses?

Of course! Many of the toddler mattresses we’ve listed on this page are hypoallergenic. Most of the CertiPUR US certified memory foam mattresses for toddlers are also hypoallergenic.

Can a baby use a toddler mattress?

No! While a toddler can use a crib mattress, it’s not advised for a baby to use a toddler’s mattress. Toddler mattresses tend to be softer and more cushioned and this can be dangerous for babies who haven’t developed the strength to flip over and might accidentally suffocate, leading to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

How firm should a toddler mattress be?

A toddler can have a more cushioned and comfortable mattress than a baby mattress. However, your little one can still benefit from a firmer mattress that supports their posture and development while they sleep.

Best Toddler Mattress – Final Thoughts

Overall, there are some excellent options available for your toddler’s bed. Any of the mattresses that made it on this list should work well for your family. Of course, you might have different preferences, so be sure to keep those in mind. For example, you might have a full size toddler bed, so you’ll need to find the best mattress for toddler beds.

When you begin looking for a mattress of any type, take a look at what’s most important to you. This can help you to narrow down your search and ensure you’re getting exactly what you’ve been looking for.

We chose the Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress because it’s versatile and can be used for cribs and beds for toddlers. It’s very affordable and durable as well. This isn’t to say that the other toddler mattresses that made this list aren’t going to hold up! We just like the Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress the best!

What’s most important is that your child has a safe and comfortable place to fall asleep at night. Moving from a crib to their first bed can be a big adjustment, so keeping them cozy can help things to go more smoothly.


About Aubrey Meister Audrey is an English teacher and writer. She enjoys the Florida beach life with her husband and puppy.